Bids are messy. Not because people do not care, but because bidding is a human sport played at speed, under pressure, with too many moving parts to ever feel perfectly controlled.
That is what I wanted to disucss with Tania Field, someone I have worked with on major tenders for years. We talked about why bids feel messy, what that mess does to people, and how leaders can stop the team spiralling into unrealistic expectations and perfectionism.
Bids are messy because you are managing yourself
For Tania, a lot of it is about how she manages herself through a bid. She cares about reputation and the feeling of control and command.
But bids do not give you perfect control. In consortium bids there are too many things at play. Human dynamics, fast change, and decisions that have to be made before you feel ready. Tania described it as “a group assignment on steroids”.
The shift is giving yourself permission to breathe in the mess. You do not know the answer on day one. You are not meant to. The bid has to unfurl over time as you get richer in your understanding of the subject matter, the criteria, the team, and the content itself.
The mess has an emotional undertone
Bids often have an emotional underpinning, because the work is high pressure and high exposure. People care about their reputation, their competence, and whether they are letting the team down. In consortium bids you also have multiple organisations watching each other, which adds another layer of tension.
Naming that emotional reality does two things. It gives people space to be human inside the process, and it stops the team treating normal bid behaviour like a failure.
Tania gave a simple example. People look at a returnable schedule and expect the content to exist immediately, as if it is a stocktake exercise. When it does not, stress spikes and people start pushing for certainty that the bid cannot give them yet. Recognising bids are iterative helps everyone stay steadier, whether you are writing, reviewing, or leading.
Group dynamics explain the chaos
Every time a group of humans comes together on a new project, you go through group dynamics. It does not matter how experienced the team is.
You form. You storm. You norm. You perform. Then you adjourn.
Storming is where people lose the plot. They expect immediate clarity and perfection. When they do not get it, they get reactive. That is where the mess starts.
Consortium bids make storming harder because you are forming a relationship at the same time as you are bidding. Under pressure, many teams do not get past norming before the bid is lodged. If you can get to performing, you get an edge. Productivity lifts and innovation shows up.
Then there is the phase people forget: Adjourning. The bid goes in, everyone goes out for a drink, and nobody properly resets. People carry the tension into the next pursuit.
Set the human dynamic first
I asked Tania what actually helps a team move through storming without it turning into drama, rework, or quiet resentment.
She said it starts with leadership and structure. Before the bid gets busy, she sits down with the bid director and the senior team and agrees on the basics: what good looks like, how the team will behave under pressure, and how decisions will get made when there is no time for a long debate.
This is where governance earns its keep. A clear meeting rhythm, decision pathways, how conflict gets handled and who owns what. Timelines, milestones, roles and responsibilities and RACI all matter, but only if they are real and used.
Tania’s point was simple. This is not admin. It is the scaffolding that keeps the team steady when the turbulence hits. Those agreements need to be set at the top, shared clearly at kickoff, easy to find and reinforced as the bid moves. People go tunnel-vision under deadlines and they default to habits. The team needs something stable to come back to when things get messy.
Perfectionism needs a place to go
Perfectionism shows up in bids all the time. It can lift quality, or it can make people miserable.
Tania’s view was that perfectionism can thrive when it shows up as attention to detail and a desire to lift the work strategically. The problem is when perfectionism turns into frustration and control.
In consortium bids, people with a fixed idea of how things should be can struggle. There are too many parties, too many opinions and too many interpretations. Those people often want control and often they cannot have it.
Tania made a useful distinction about reviews. The person who has been on the bid from day one has usually done the hard work of getting the content to the best possible position within the reality of that tender. Without them, the bid does not get submitted.
Reviewers often come in later with fresh eyes and high standards. That can elevate the response, but it can also land as “not good enough” if it comes at the wrong time or without context.
Tania also owned her own perfectionism. She said she is a perfectionist by heart, but she is also a team player. She has learned to prioritise what she calls best for bid. If the sentiment is right, it does not have to be said her way.
Performing in bids looks different
I asked Tania how a team ever gets from norming to performing on a major bid.
Her answer was honest. Time matters, and bids do not always give you time. In consortium and JV bids, the team is different every time. You are reintroducing yourselves on every pursuit. Expecting a high performing team immediately can be unrealistic.
That led us into a bigger question about clients bringing bids to market. If procurement wants consortium bids, innovation, and high quality, but only gives six weeks, what are they really asking for.
Tania made a good point. Procurement teams are reading the same time constraints we are living inside. They may be assessing bids with a realistic view of what can be achieved in the timeframe.
Under pressure, teams can be forced into a version of performing. It might not look tidy, but it can still be exceptional.
Redefine success so the work is sustainable
We finished where we started. Bids are messy.
The work is not to pretend they are not. The work is to set the human dynamic early, keep the team steady through agreed principles and rhythms, and cut people some slack so they can do exceptional strategy without burning out.
If we want people to stay in this profession, we need to reset expectations, allow for the emotional reality of bidding, and accept that normal in tenders looks different to normal in projects.
-
Deb: [00:00:00] Welcome to Chasing the Win three organisations. Fully aligned subject matter experts [00:01:00] available at your absolute beck and call. Every returnable schedule is a hundred percent clear. Who are we kidding? Bids are messy, but Tanya Field is here with me, and today we're here to explore the method in the madness.
You've often said bids are messy, and we've explored that a lot over the years, and I wanted to pose that question back to you. Why are bids messy and what does it mean for somebody in the profession to recognise that they are?
Tania: For me, a lot of it is always about how do I manage myself through a bid?
Because a lot of it for me is reputational that I have control and command, um, of what I do. And I think by the nature of a bid and some of the large consortium bids that we work on, there is so many things at play. Um, human, it's like a group assignment on [00:02:00] steroids, and so therefore, you know, the human dynamics, the, and then all reaching towards a deadline at the end and the fast pace of change and the decision making required can make you feel, if you're a perfectionist, feel slightly out of depth, out of your comfort zone.
Feeling a bit messy is the best way I can describe it. And I guess by that virtue, for me, it was probably a philosophy I needed to put on myself or to give to myself permission to breathe in that space and allow myself to go. Okay. Um, because I don't know the answer today. That's okay. By nature, the bid evolves over time as we get richer in our understanding of the subject matter, the complex criteria, the team, the, the content personality.
Exactly. The content of the bid. So, yeah. So, um, or the organisation, therefore, I need to [00:03:00] give myself permission to allow myself to have time to understand it and play in that messy space.
Deb: It's really got an emotional underpinning. And, and that's not surprising. I mean, if you, if we describe kind of the dynamic that you mostly work within, I don't think that you've been on a tender in the last five years that hasn't had at least three major parties involved.
Tania: That's right.
Deb: I mean, one of them was 18 months long. In effect, it had three, three periods with a constant pressurised dynamic.
Tania: Yep.
Deb: We bring ourselves to bids that emotional underpinning is something that people maybe they're fearful to address and it does give them space to realise they're allowed to be human Yeah.
Within it.
Tania: Yeah. It definitely does, but it also kind of puts people at bay that have an ex an an expectation that is unrealistic.
Deb: Okay.
Tania: As to knowing. Um, so for example, jumping into a returnable schedule and having an expectation that [00:04:00] the content should be there immediately. Yeah. Whereas it has to unfurl over time.
So it, it goes both ways.
Deb: Is a recognition that bids are actually far more iterative than people realise.
Tania: A hundred percent. The way I see it, it keeps an even keel for everyone in the team. It's holistic. It's from a a for a reviewer, it's for a, uh, a person writing. It's for a subject matter expert. It's for everyone involved.
Deb: It's interesting that you mentioned, it's the group dynamic. So, you know, that I'm a, I'm a strong believer in informing people about group dynamics in bids. Mm-hmm. Um, and let's just, let's just define that for a second so that the people listening understand what we're talking about. Every single time a group of human beings come together every single time, no matter what, even teams like ours that are coherent and cohesive and work together every day, every time we come together on a new initiative, a new activity, a new project, we go through the five phases of group dynamics.
Mm-hmm. [00:05:00] We form. Mm-hmm. We come together, we storm. Mm-hmm. We lose the plot. Basically. Humans just lose the plot. We have to, we have to know stuff immediately. We expect immediate perfectionism. We expect complete clarity straight away. Unless we get that complete clarity, we don't know where we are. And to me, that's where the definition of the mess actually starts.
The bids are messy, is not recognising that there is a storming phase, and just to go through the rest of them quickly and we'll come back to the storming phase. So it's, it's forming, it's storming, it's norming. And I honestly think not many organisations get past that in a tender.
Tania: Mm-hmm.
Deb: Under, under the pressure They're in, particularly in consortium bids where you are forming a relationship at the same time as bidding.
I don't think they get past norming.
Tania: Mm-hmm.
Deb: But if you can get past norming, you get an edge because you get to performing, and that's where you end up with high performance. You end up with greater productivity. That's where innovation comes to the [00:06:00] fore. And then the one that people always forget, they, they, the bid goes in, we all go to the pub.
Um, we have one too many glasses of wine because we are tired, and then we forget to adjourn. That's where we need to regroup and, and, and embrace ourselves again as an individual outside of that group dynamic.
Tania: Mm-hmm.
Deb: So I'm a big fan of that. Yeah. That, and I, and we've talked about it a lot. So back in the storming phase.
If bids are messy, and you, you, you set this, it's not a low expectation. It's in a, an emotional acknowledgement with the bid team that bids are messy. What can we do in the storming phase to support people to get them through that phase as quickly as possible?
Tania: Well, from my perspective, going in as a major submission manager would be sitting down with a bid director or that very senior team and agreeing the fundamental principles and behaviours that we [00:07:00] need to play as a team moving forward.
Deb: Yep.
Tania: So getting them on board, either if that happens by virtue of a strategy session or it's a separate one around culture. Mm. It's a very quick conversation around even governance and management. And I know it's gonna sound boring and it might not sound attached to it, but even just the structure of your meetings and how you come together over that period of time.
Mm-hmm. And I would strongly recommend that those are agreed at the top level. Therefore it then just gets shared broadly throughout the team and supported in terms of how you are collegiate and you work effectively and cooperatively together.
Deb: So we're actually setting the human dynamic first.
Tania: A hundred percent.
Deb: Yeah. Set that. How are we gonna engage as disparate organisations? Mm-hmm. How are we gonna engage as a group of individuals coming together that have never worked together before, or some of us might have, but this dynamic is new, this entire [00:08:00] tender is new. We are gonna have interesting, thrown things thrown at us from left field all the time.
Tania: Yeah.
Deb: Agreeing what conflict, how, how to resolve conflict. Agreeing what else? Agreeing what, what, what aspects do you feel we need to agree in that human dynamic, in that storming phase?
Tania: Again, just behaviours, central things like timeline, milestones, getting the basic stuff as well. Um, uh, agreeing roles and responsibilities, races.
Um, it, it's, uh, all of the fundamentals to project management.
Deb: Yeah.
Tania: And then really. You know, as a submission manager, making those recommendations, getting that agreement, getting that rub out of the way very quickly. Mm-hmm. And then sitting everyone into a room, uh, sorry, bringing everyone into a room together for a kickoff meeting and fundamentally sharing that view
Deb: mm-hmm.
Tania: And making it available and constantly, uh, and by that I mean on SharePoint in a format that was presented to the team and continuously [00:09:00] coming back to that and re-affirming it and reconfirming it the whole way through. So, because the, the nature of us in bidding is we become blind through the process of deadlines, responding to schedules, the overwhelm, the questions, and we become reactionary.
Deb: Yeah.
Tania: And therefore we need, I guess that, I don't know what you'd call it on a, on a boat. It's a, what, what, what keeps the boat level, um, out sailing the, you know what I mean? The, not the rudder, but the, I've lost, I've lost my point. Now. Should we stop?
Deb: What does that mean? Is it the,
Tania: I dunno, is it the, you know, ke and even keel?
Keel. Keel. The
Deb: keel.
Tania: See, we've just been saying that heaps this week. We're like looking at you going, are you gonna say it?
Deb: Ah, okay. Um, let's keep this in. Um, yeah, so, so I believe the, I believe that [00:10:00] the word is keel. Keel, yes. Yeah. So even kill the sailing metaphor just sailed off in another direction.
Tania: I think the choppy waters will occur, the turbulence in, in the air of a plane, you know?
Yeah. It, it. And so therefore we have to come back to the common principles and just reconfirm it at every point in time, stick to our timelines, stick to the gates where they are, and, and everything becomes revealed at that time. That needs to reveal itself in terms of the input, the, the approval, whatever.
Yeah. So
Deb: it's really interesting because I, I just think mess. So I'm thinking messy bids are messy. They don't have to be, but they are. And, and
Tania: they're okay to be messy too,
Deb: but that's it. We're giving ourselves permission to acknowledge that they, that they are. So where does the perfectionist sit? And I think we're still, we're, we're not just in the storming phase here, we're heading into the norming phase.
Where does the perfectionist sit? If, if bids are messy, [00:11:00] can you have a perfectionist type of temperament and survive?
Tania: I think you can, that comes into play with attention to detail, um, and desire to always lift, elevate something to a strategic level. So I think perfectionism thrives in that space.
Deb: Mm.
Tania: The process needs to be allowed to be what it is, and the perfectionists probably need to be at bay a little bit, if that makes sense.
So, and, and the best example of that is, for me, a reviewer and a reviewer's feedback coming in at the right time, which I think sometimes they come from a position of perfectionism and something's not good enough.
Deb: Mm.
Tania: Whereas, and this is gonna sound like I'm jumping all over the place because it's, it's very real at the moment for us, is the person who's been on the bid from day one, the whole way up to that point it gets reviewed, has probably to a certain extent become kind of, sort of [00:12:00] not beaten down by the process, but their expectations have been lowered.
Deb: Mm-hmm.
Tania: And therefore they've gotten the sub, the subject matter to the best possible position that they can
Deb: within the dynamic of
Tania: that tender, which is a really important role that they've played.
Deb: Yes.
Tania: Because without them, the bid wouldn't get submitted.
Deb: Yeah.
Tania: But then the perfectionist, I think is not that person necessarily.
It's the people who come in and do the review.
Deb: Okay.
Tania: Who help elevate it. I don't know if that's too obscure and
Deb: thought No, no. I think, I think you've got some food for thought there. I mean, I, I suppose I'm also thinking about. Just a temperament bidding generally. Sure. I find that perfectionists become the most frustrated.
So if, so, if there's a, a, a bid manager or a writer that is a perfectionist and they have a very set idea in their head about the way in which things should be in a consortium based bid with [00:13:00] multiple parties, multiple different opinions, multiple, multiple different interpretations of things, those people can become very frustrated very easily.
And then they're the people that normally also with their particular accountabilities, wanna be in control and often they're not.
Tania: Mm-hmm.
Deb: Um, and that's another reason why bids are messy. And that's another reason why they can be emotional animals.
Tania: I would say I'm a, I am a perfectionist.
Deb: Oh. And not Right.
You hide it. Well
Tania: declare it.
Deb: Yeah. Go on.
Tania: But I am also a team player. Yes. So I know how to let go of it for, I'm gonna say best bid.
Deb: You've learnt that over time.
Tania: I have both.
Deb: Yeah.
Tania: And I think I will always prioritise getting the bid in the box, so to speak,
Deb: over your own fulfilment of your
Tania: perfectionism. A hundred percent.
But I am always privy to and working with people who [00:14:00] would like to lead the outcome in a lot of regards and be the, the winner in that argument of cerebral governance over the understanding of criteria. Right? Like there's so many of us who, who come at this with the best intention of intention, but my role in that regard is to sort of get the best of both worlds.
Um, so I'm gonna come back to I'm a perfectionist by heart. I know how to do best for bid. I will therefore, um, pri deprioritize my own kind of requirements.
Deb: Mm-hmm.
Tania: I also have an ability to be able to go, just because it's not said the way that I want it to say. If it says, if the sentiment of it is the same, then we are good.
Deb: Yep.
Tania: So the perfectionist
Deb: has to learn to let go, has
Tania: to learn to step back and go, best forbid.
Deb: Yep. And that's also part of the group dynamics. So if we get to [00:15:00] this concept of norming, once people get through that storming process and they get clarity about their roles and responsibilities, and that's why leadership upfront, setting the parameters, you call it the sides of the pool.
Yeah. I just need to know where the sides of the pool are, Deb. I'm like, okay, here are the sides of the pool. Once it, once the leadership is there and the parameters are set, people then can start norming and then they know what they can argue against, but what they also have to let go. Mm-hmm. And a perfectionist can then survive in that environment if bids are messy and you're always thrown.
Things from left field and clients throw addendum at you and, I don't know, scope changes and, um, decisions aren't being made, uh, as quickly as we need them to be made. How does a team ever get a bid team on a major bid ever get from norming to performing? What, what are the key steps there? [00:16:00]
Tania: I think it's time.
I'll be really honest.
Deb: Wow.
Tania: I I
Deb: time that you don't have under a bid.
Tania: Yeah. But I think it's, I think often people would say we were in the trenches together.
Deb: Yeah.
Tania: Once you have at least 24 hours post the bid. 'cause you probably hate everyone in the bid. And once the, once the bid's been lodged, let's be real about this.
Yeah. You pro you, like, you'll go out for a drink or whatever, and then you just go, or a meal. I don't wanna
Deb: see you
Tania: for another week. Exactly.
Deb: Yeah.
Tania: Um, because it's, and it's okay to have those feelings. Yeah. 'cause you're in the most incredibly stressful times. So, you know, we've gotta cut ourselves some slack a little bit there.
Mm-hmm.
Deb: But you were in the trenches together,
Tania: but you're in the trenches together. Yeah. So, so therefore, from, from my perspective, and I'll be honest with you, as a major submission manager, as long as I've done my job in just guiding people through the process with a firm hand and a steady, a steady and firm hand the whole way.
Deb: Mm.
Tania: I, I [00:17:00] have fundamentally become the rock and the support system for all of the other craziness that's going on around us. Yeah. I can't say that essentially the team is performing to the utmost extent. I think you need more time for something to perform
Deb: Yeah.
Tania: In a big environment. It just happens over time.
Yeah. So therefore you, you know how to get the answer quicker. You know how to sit down with the right person, have a quick conversation and triage whatever the issue was. Yeah. To get things back on track.
Deb: Yeah.
Tania: I feel like maybe the expectation for this high performing, high functioning bid team
Deb: might be a little bit unrealistic in the, in some of the timeframes that
Tania: are set.
Deb: Well,
Tania: because the bids that you are talking to me about mm-hmm. Are consortium JV bids. Yeah. And they're different people every single time.
Deb: Mm-hmm.
Tania: It's not like the same group that does a bid one after the other together.
Deb: No.
Tania: We're reintroducing ourselves every time. So
Deb: yeah.
Tania: That expectation to get to that [00:18:00] kind of cooking with gas immediately, I just, I think that's probably unrealistic.
Deb: I think it actually raises an interesting point though, in clients bringing bids to market. And not actually giving enough time to form Storm Norm and, and perform. Yeah. That they're almost doing themselves a disservice in saying, we're gonna put this to market. We're gonna ask for consorted consortia to bid on this.
They've just formed, they don't even know the definition of their scope or their partnership yet. And we are gonna ask them to put forward their most innovative and their highest quality response for this incredibly highly technical area of expertise in the space of six weeks.
Tania: Yeah.
Deb: Crazy. Crazy.
Tania: Yeah.
Deb: Crazy. So maybe there is something that, that we actually need to start to, I don't know, raise awareness [00:19:00] around the group dynamics of, of tenders and, and try to get that in front of clients like, like for ultimate end clients, government clients make procurement understand what they're actually demanding of three or four disparate organisations coming together to create something exceptional.
Tania: Agreed.
Deb: Maybe bids are messy needs to be to, to be, uh, part of, part of the dialogue.
Tania: Yeah. And I think also probably understanding the perspective of procurement more to really know, do they have the same expectation as us on that? So maybe we've created that expectation for ourselves.
Deb: So is our definition of what good looks like actually the same as what procurement was?
Hundred percent. See,
Tania: a hundred percent.
Deb: I hadn't thought of it that way.
Tania: Well, I kind of think that everyone's reasonably high functioning and smart and thinks about this stuff.
Deb: One, one would like to assume, but
Tania: you, you gotta think that they're receiving stuff. And, and I think also, you know, the amount of human [00:20:00] errors you making in a bid, the things you probably would've said differently if you had more time.
They're receiving that and they're reading that as well, and they're probably going, well, that's a bit of a funny statement. Or, you know, so I think, I guess what I'm saying is I guess there must be a level where they read it and they recognise what can be achieved in time. You'd hope.
Deb: I understand. So you, so they read it and they actually see something really quite compelling.
And for organisations who've never really worked together, some have, some haven't. But in that dynamic, have managed to do that in a Exactly, in a period of six weeks. I've never looked at it that way. That's actually a really wonderful thing to think about that these group dynamics, because they're under pressure.
It's like forging the diamond because they are under pressure. But unfortunately we don't have the time that a diamond takes because they're under pressure and because that time is constrained, they're actually forced.
Tania: [00:21:00] Hmm.
Deb: In a way to perform.
Tania: Mm-hmm.
Deb: You philosophically got me, got me changing my mind mid podcast because I've always said that, that organisations never really quite get to performing, but you are making me rethink that.
Maybe they actually do. And what we are seeing, because bids are messy, is an exceptional outcome from a really challenging
Tania: Absolutely.
Deb: Process and environment.
Tania: Yeah. That's why I would say the whole way through a bid, we try and create that culture of celebration or just acknowledgement and congratulations, like sounds silly, like gold Star of the week and that sort of stuff.
Deb: People love your gold star of the week. Well, they were vying for it. They were performing for it.
Tania: It sounds so, it makes me feel like I'm in kindergarten or something again.
Deb: But, um, praise is praise is nice at any age.
Tania: Yeah. But I think, I think we have to cut ourselves some slack. Um, and, and from a, my perspective of being a, a [00:22:00] leader as you are and wanting to build people to stay in this as a sustainable profession moving forward
Deb: Mm.
Tania: Some of this kind of tension and kind of unrealistic expectations or this kind of perfect perfectionism that, that we need to whittle this down into something that is the profession, which is doing exceptional strategy. We need to have a, a bid version of what performing is.
Deb: We, we need to redefine, redefine what performing, redefine what success is in the context of what we do
Tania: so that people who come from a project environment start to talk more in a bid bid bid type environment.
And I've worked with leaders who were project managers of made and um, like billions of dollars that they've led projects exceptionally skilled, and they come into a bid team environment and they're not the right skill set for, for that bid team environment. They drive a different outcome, they have different expectations.
They set up infrastructure that is far too, uh, robust. Long term doesn't [00:23:00] work short term. Yeah. So
Deb: it doesn't have the flexibility and malleability
Tania: Exactly. That
Deb: messy bids need.
Tania: Exactly. So I think there's a reframing that we need to go through Mm.
Deb: In
Tania: regards to, and a resetting of expectations and an an allowance for us to sort of, um, I don't know, be a bit emotional through that process as well.
Yep. Um, and, and accept a, a different type of normal
Deb: and really accept that bids are messy
Tania: a hundred percent.